I just finished a 5th grade 3-Act task called Penny Cube that I created last spring. I tried it then, but just to get some feedback from students and see what I might need to change about how the task should be presented. Now, after completing this task with two groups of students (at two different points in the year), I’ve learned three things:

- Students see a video and notice a bunch of things that teachers don’t even realize are there.
- The curious questions students ask first are often “why” questions.
- There’s no way to predict everything a group of students might wonder.

I’ll take this reflection from the beginning. First, I let students know that I was going to show them a video clip. I also told them that I was going to ask them what they noticed when it was finished playing. I gave students a chance to brainstorm ideas about what they could do to make sure they would be able to share what they noticed once the clip had finished playing. Their ideas were amazing:

- We could look for expressions (on faces – I found out later that this student was thinking about context. A person’s facial expression can tell a lot) Unfortunately, there were no facial expressions in this video.
- Listen carefully (they might be able to hear something that might give them a clue about what was going on – these students were already expecting a problem situation!)
- Stay focused on the clip.
- Take notes.
- Try to remember as much as you can.

I had never done this before, but after hearing their ideas, I will be using this again.

After showing the video clip for Act 1, I immediately had them talk about what they noticed with their groups. Then, they were asked to share with the whole group. Here is what they noticed:

What’s missing from this picture is the wonderful reasoning given for some of these. For the last bullet, “container is open in the front,” the student told the class that it was open in front so the pennies could be placed in the container more easily (I never thought they’d see or think about that). They even began to wonder a bit here – “it might be an expression or it might be counting.” My favorite, though, is the estimation by the girl who said “it looks like 100 pennies in the stack ($1.00).” This was particularly interesting to me because of what happened when they were asked to estimate for the focus question.

The wonders were typical from what I usually get from students new to 3-Act tasks, but I handled it a bit differently this time. Here are their wonders (click here for a typed version of Penny Cube Notices&Wonders):

In my limited (yet growing) experience with teaching using 3-Act tasks, I’ve noticed that the wonders are initially “why” questions (as stated in number 2 above). I told the class that I noticed that the questions they were asking were mostly “why” questions. I asked them what other words could be used to begin questions. Rather than trying to steer students to a particular question, I decided to focus the students’ attention on the kinds of questions they were already asking, and guide them to other types of questions. It didn’t take long! Within about 5 minutes, students had gone from “why” questions to “how many . . .” and “how much . . .” questions which are much easier to answer mathematically.

The students were then asked to figure out what they needed to solve the problem. From experience with this task, I knew that most students would want pennies, so I had some ready. I didn’t give them the Coin Specifications sheet, because no one asked for it. I did have it ready, just in case. Every group asked for pennies and rulers. I wasn’t sure how they would use them, but I was pleasantly surprised.

Here’s what they did:

The students all started in a place that made sense to them. Some wanted to figure out how many in the stack, so they stacked pennies and quickly realized (as I did when filling the cube) that you can’t stack pennies very high before they start to wobble and fall. So, they measured smaller stacks and used that info to solve the problem. Others wanted to find number of pennies along an edge to find how many cover the base, then work on the stacks. Students were thoroughly engaged.

After three 1 hour classes, students were wrapping up their solutions. Some groups were still grappling with the number of pennies in a stack. Others were finished. A few were unsure about what to do with some of the numbers they generated. All of this told the classroom teacher and me that there were some misconceptions out there that needed to be addressed. Many of the misconceptions had to do with students disengaging from the context, rather than integrating their numbers into the context:

- One group was unsure of whether to multiply the number of pennies in a stack by 12 (6 inches + 6 inches) or to use 64.
- Another group found the number of pennies to cover the base and multiplied it by itself to get their solution.
- A third group found 37 pennies in 2 1/2 inches and was having a difficult time handling that information.
- A fourth group had come up with two different solutions and both thought they were correct. Only one could defend her solution.

Eventually, several groups arrived a solution that made sense to them.

Time to share!

I chose one group to share. This group had a reasonable solution, but their method and numbers were different from many of the other groups, so this is where we were hoping for some light bulbs to begin to glow a bit.

This group shared their work:

I asked the class what they liked about the work. The responses:

- The math (computations) are written neatly and they’re easy to follow.
- I know what their answer is because it has a bubble around it.
- The question is on it.
- It’s colorful.

All good. Now, for the best part:

What questions do you have for this group? The responses:

- Where did you get 34?
- What does the 102 mean?
- How about the 64?

Any suggestions for this group to help them clarify their work to answer some of your questions?

- Maybe they could label their numbers so we know what the numbers mean.
- Maybe they could tell what the answer means too. Like put it in a sentence so it says something like “6,528 pennies will fit in the container.”
- Maybe they could have a diagram to show how they got a number like 64 or 34. I know that would help me (this student had a diagram on his work and thought it was useful).

The light bulbs really started to glow as students began making suggestions. As soon as a suggestion was made, students began to check their own work to see if it was on their work. If it wasn’t, they added it. All of the suggestions were written on the board so they could modify their work one final time. The best part about this whole exchange was that students were suggesting to their peers to be more precise in their mathematics (SMP 6 – Attend to precision). And, they really wanted to know what 34 was because they didn’t have that number on their boards (which is why I chose this group).

Now for the reveal! When I asked the class if they wanted to know how many pennies were in the cube, they were surprised when I pulled up the reveal the video. I guess they thought I’d just tell them (that’s so 1980’s). They watched to see how close they were and when the total came up on the screen, many cheered because they were so close!

The students in this class were engaged in multiple content standards over the course of 3 days. They reasoned, critiqued, made sense, and persevered. It’s almost difficult to believe that this class was a “remedial” class!

Below, I’ve included a picture of each group’s final work.

Finally, one of the conversations witnessed in a group was between a girl and a boy and should have been caught on video, but wasn’t. This group had an incorrect solution, but they were convinced they were correct, so to keep them thinking about the problem, I asked them how many dollars would be equal to the number of pennies in their answer (3,616).

- Girl: There are 100 pennies in a dollar. So 600 pennies is . . .
- Boy in group: $6.00
- Girl (after a long pause): 1,000 pennies equals $10.00
- Boy: So that’s . . . um. . .
- Me: How does knowing 1,000 pennies = $10.00 help you.
- Girl: We have 3,000 pennies, so that’s $30.00.
- Boy: $36.00
- Me: Share with your group how you know it’s $36.00
- Boy: Because $30.00 and $6.00 is $36.00
- Girl: And the rest (16) are cents. $36.16!

And they didn’t even need a calculator!

Math really does make sense!

Great stuff Mike!

There are many things you’ve shared here that I am definitely going to use moving forward. My takeaways:

-How the students were challenged to ask questions that don’t start with “why”. The questions that start with “why” are really hard to quantify and make measurable. Love this!

-Your use of open questions. I’m really thankful that you included your questioning throughout this post because it’s something that I am continually trying to improve.

-The way you set up the video before showing to engage more students and curiosity.

Maybe I wish you were teaching in the 80’s…because then you could have been my teacher!

Thanks Graham!

The challenge to the students to ask questions other than “why” questions was experimental and I will continue to adapt how I use it. Continuing to improve my “least helpful” questioning is always a goal of mine.

If I was teaching in the 80’s, I could’ve been my teacher! How old are you?

Hello, Mike. I left a comment on the task itself but I’m not sure it posted…

Anyway, I tried this task with my three classes of fifth graders, and it was a huge hit! The students were fascinated, came up with awesome questions of their own (including what would happen if different coins a different shaped object were used). This was the first 3-Act Task I have ever tried, and I am now a true believer in the power of using real-world problems in mathematics. My district’s math coordinator observed that day and before we knew it, we were both on the floor with the students as they tried different strategies and altered their conjectures. Thank you so much for sharing your tasks with the rest of us!

It did. Your story is inspiring and I will be sharing it (probably as soon as tomorrow) at a PL in my district. It’s great to hear about student (and teacher) successes with 3-acts. If there’s anything I can do from my end to help you with these tasks or help you get others in your school started, please don’t hesitate to contact me.

Mike

PS: I left further comments to your initial post.

Marian,

Not sure why you can’t find the post? I’ll see if I can do anything on my end to help out. Please try some more. The fact that you’re trying them is huge. What a great way to for you to empower your students. Keep up the good work and maybe try one of the ideas for the penny cube sequels?

Mike